The European Council on Foreign Relations

Ukraine decides, second round: part two

By Andrew Wilson - 04 Feb 10

Another Election Fix?

Ukraine's boorish MPs have always liked agood fight in parliament, but on Wednesday they had good cause, whenYanukovych's supporters succeeded in changing the election law only four daysbefore the final vote. Changing the rules in the middle of the game is ofcourse a major scandal, and Ukrainehad been specifically warned against doing so by the OSCE and the VeniceCommission (which makes recommendations on constitutional law to members of theCouncil of Europe).

Parliamentmade three key changes. The provision for election committees to make consensualdecisions via a 2/3rds quorum was abolished - increasing the risk of partisanbias. Any vacancies can now be filled by local authorities, which are alsooften highly partisan in the different regions of Ukraine. In the east they arecontrolled by Yanukovych's supporters, in the centre by Tymoshenko's. Higherlevel commissions have greater powers to intervene in the decisions of lowercommissions.

The changesdo not make fraud inevitable, but they weaken the insurance mechanisms that aredesigned to stop it.

Tymoshenkohas cried foul, lobbying G8 ambassadors, the OSCE and the internationalcommunity at large to protest. She has talked of a new Orange Revolution ifPresident Yushchenko signs the law. She is perfectly entitled to protest,though she is also trying to mobilise her own supporters - and has been lookingfor something to complain about. Yushchenko signed the law with vulgaralacrity.

Twenty ninemembers of his Our Ukraine block voted for the bill on Wednesday, increasingthe possibility that they could defect to Yanukovych if he wins the presidency.This places the existing precarious parliamentary majority that backsTymoshenko as prime minister under threat.

Yanukovych'ssupporters meanwhile have reminded the world that they have never come to termswith, or even admitted, what they did in 2004.

For more...

Read Andrew's first blog post on Tymoshenko

For the press...Andrew is available for interviews. Click here for our press advisory.

 


Comments

There are no comments for this entry yet. Get the discussion started and post below.

Submit a Comment

Your message will be submitted to a moderator before appearing online. Name and email address are required, all other fields are optional. Your email will not be displayed.

Please enter the word you see in the image below:

Remember my personal information

Latest Publications

The EU and Azerbaijan: Beyond Oil

How Europe can promote democracy in Azerbaijan

How France and Germany can make Europe work

Hollande and Merkel should launch an ambitious EU reform programme

China and Germany: a new special relationship?

Why the emerging special relationship matters for Europe

China Analysis: Taiwan after the election

How will Taiwan’s relationship with China evolve? 

Jordan: Reform before it’s too late

Europe should take a more assertive approach to political reform in Jordan

China at the crossroads: are the reformers winning the argument?

China is facing a choice between regress and reform

How the EU can support reform in Burma

Europe can help Burma reform, but its help must be gradual

Syria: Towards a Political Solution

An end to the bloodshed may necessitate talks with the regime

The end of the Putin consensus

Putin's return: why Europe should prepare for a weaker Putin

The long shadow of ordoliberalism: Germany's approach to the euro crisis

The thinking behind Germany's unpopular approach to the crisis

European Foreign Policy Scorecard 2012

How well did European foreign policy perform over the last year?

Reinvention of Europe

In the Press

Presseurop
22 May 12

ECFR's policy brief on China and Germany is discussed

El Tiempo
22 May 12

Nicholas Walton is quoted in an article about the trial of General Mladic

Le Monde
21 May 12

ECFR's policy brief on China and Germany quoted

The Moscow News
21 May 12

Nick Witney quoted on NATO Chicago Summit and missile shield

Read more press >

Publications side bar