The European Council on Foreign Relations

Ukraine decides: the questions to ask

By Andrew Wilson - 11 Feb 10

So what should we expect from President Yanukovych? Of course that assumes that Yuliya Tymoshenko's appeal against the election of Viktor Yanukovych doesn't succeed. But putting that aside, it's right that the real focus of attention shifts to what we should expect from Mr Yanukovych. Here are some thoughts on the questions that we now need to be asking.

One big question is whether he will adjust to the reality of a limited mandate. He didn't win big, and is the first Ukrainian President to be elected with less than 50% of the vote. Will he reach out to his opponents? Will be have a strategy for building bridges to the other half of the country that didn't vote for him? Yushchenko never did, and it cost him dearly in the end.  

A related decision will be on the type of new government he tries to set up (it seems highly unlikely he will leave Tymoshenko as PM). The new government will be full of businessmen, but what type of businessmen? Will he try and find a place for Serhiy Tihipko? Will he appoint pragmatic ministers or what is known in Kiev as the 'TKM tendency' (from the phrase used by the Polish left in private when they returned to power in the 1990s - 'teraz kurwa my' - 'It's our f...ing turn'). Will he allow the same guys to run the gas industry as in 2006-7?

What favours does he owe Dmytro Firtash, former boss of Rosukrenergo, who was supposedly a major contributor to his campaign? Yanukovych has talked of renegotiating Ukraine's various gas deals, and of setting up a Russo-Ukrainian consortium, open to European participation, to run the Ukrainian gas system. Will this be compatible with the gas deal Ukraine signed with the EU in 2009? Will Yanukovych increase prices to domestic consumers, so that the key company Oil and Gas of Ukraine actually has a viable business model? Will he reform, and invest in, the country's creaking energy infrastructure?

The gas issue is key to rebuilding relations with the EU. What about the oligarchs whose business interests are blocking parts of the Association Agreement?

Yanukovych does not want a NATO Membership Action Plan, but then nor did Tymoshenko. Will Yanukovych keep practical cooperation going with NATO? He was happy to do so during his two previous stints as Prime Minister.

Russia's lease on its Black Sea base at Sevastopol runs out in 2017. The issue will need to be addressed in the second half of this next presidential term. There are rumours that Yanukovych will consider not just a renewal, but a Guantanamo-style lease for 30 years or more.

Yanukovych has never formally withdrawn the promise he made to recognise Abkhazia and South Ossetia in the aftermath of the war in Georgia in 2008. He hasn't exactly talked much about it since, but has always declined to ditch the promise when pressed in public, which has been often enough.

And what will he do with Ukraine's troublingly free media? The signs are that he might try and shift the ownership of a few outlets, but will be unable to introduce anything like the censorship of the Kuchma era.

I appreciate that these are questions rather than answers, but that in itself says a lot about what Ukraine faces under a Yanukovych presidency. Both Ukrainians and world leaders will have to get used to their often boorish new president - and to the fact that he will preside over the European Championship football final in 2012. 

Andrew has been blogging throughout the Ukrainian elections. Here is the previous entry

Listen to his special podcast interview with two eminent Ukrainians, Olexiy Haran and Mykola Ryabchuk, here 

For the press...Andrew is available for interviews. Click here for our press advisory.

 


2 Comments

#1

Some expert, Mr. Wilson you show your shallowness with your use of the preposition “the” before Ukraine

Zen | Toronto | 14 Feb 10, 14 Feb 10 EST
#2

a few more questions: how much will democracy suffer in the next 5 years?  how ironic is it that McCain consultants aided a canidate with an anti-nato platform?  how likely is it that Yanokovich pays any attention to the east-west division of Ukraine?

Chris | Kyiv | 17 Feb 10, 17 Feb 10 EST

Submit a Comment

Your message will be submitted to a moderator before appearing online. Name and email address are required, all other fields are optional. Your email will not be displayed.

Please enter the word you see in the image below:

Remember my personal information

Latest Publications

A danger or an opportunity? Post-Copenhagen China and climate change

This latest edition of “China Analysis” looks at the response to the Copenhagen conference within China itself, as it faces the worst environment position imaginable, threatening its systems and interests. 

A global China policy

China is now a huge foreign policy challenge to the EU: it must respond with a global China policy.

Beyond wait-and-see: the way forward for EU Balkan policy

Risk of instability in the Western Balkans: the EU can no longer 'wait-and-see'.

Dealing with Yanukovych’s Ukraine

The Yanukovych Paradox: How Ukraine’s new president can be good news for Europe after all.

China shapes its post-crisis economic agenda

The latest issue of China Analysis looks at Beijing’s willingness to strengthen international economic governance, and its authors argue that much thinking in China seems to focus on the short term

China and India: rivals always, partners sometimes

The authors of the latest issue of China Analysis argue that Western concerns over “Chindia” - the emergence of a Sino-Indian economic power bloc or strategic alliance - may be unwarranted. 

Towards a post-American Europe: A Power Audit of EU-US Relations by Nick Witney & Jeremy Shapiro

Europe has the US president it wished for, but does Barack Obama have the strong transatlantic partner he wants?

Can the EU rebuild failing states? A review of Europe’s civilian capacities.

Have broken promises and treating Afghanistan, DR Congo and Iraq like Bosnia left the EU without the capacity to prevent fragile states from becoming failing states?

What does Russia think?

ECFR publishes a collection of views from key Russian intellectuals.

The EU and human rights at the UN: 2009 annual review

The EU’s ongoing loss of influence at the UN is putting lives at risk, argues the author of ECFR’s latest paper.

In the Press

Les Echos - 01 Sep 10

Thomas Klau on Germany’s linchpin role in the eurozone governance debate.

Wall Street Journal - 30 Aug 10

Ulrike Guerot on Germany's place in Europe, post euro crisis.

Radio Free Europe - 24 Aug 10

Andrew Wilson says Ukraine's greatest success has been its 'survival'.

Read more press >

Click here for ECFR's Youtube channel.

Global Calendar